CTC.A · · Past
Canadian Tire’s sales beat our forecast
Actual event
Comparable sales rose 3.2%, normalized diluted EPS rose 13% to C$4.27, and the annual dividend increased to C$7.30.
Released Vancouver time
Issuer releaseResearch work
Analysis published
Results verified · Event analysis published
The stronger quarter improves the earnings starting point. At the Nov. 13 C$220.32 close, the preliminary five-year model yields 5.5% annualized versus 6.6% for XIC. The full equity report and valuation review are pending, including cash conversion and the capital it takes to sustain dividends and buybacks.
Valuation under reviewSee the preliminary valuation →
Next check Watch holiday comparable sales, the ex-fuel gross margin and credit losses. Reconcile full-year operating cash, retail capex and financial-services funding before setting a buy ceiling.
Trade decision
Wait on Canadian Tire
The stronger quarter still leaves a lower modeled base return than XIC at C$220.32. The preliminary bear case loses 17.3% over five years.
Revisit About C$209.19 matches XIC in the base case. Revisit below that level or if the holiday results support more durable margins and cash conversion.
Expected stock-price impact
Scored-2.5% expected stock move
About $200.00 from the Nov 10, 2026 close of $205.11
We would wait for the report before adding. We expect flagship sales to recover, but see a risk that promotions and expenses limit the improvement in retail profit.
- Bear-7% to -5%
Weak sales and margin pressure carry into the holiday outlook, making a larger earnings cut likely.
- Base-2.5%
Sales recover, but promotions or expenses absorb much of the gain. Investors cut roughly C$0.40 from 2027 EPS.
- Bull+3% to +5%
Flagship sales recover, gross margin holds, and underlying retail profit improves enough to support higher 2027 estimates.
The expectations gap
A published estimate snapshot puts 2027 EPS at C$15.54, up about 9%. Our working estimate is C$14.85, about 4% below that snapshot. In Q2, normalized EPS rose 10.4%, helped by a lower share count, while normalized retail pretax profit rose 1.2% and flagship comparable sales fell 0.8%. We assume roughly 4% EPS growth until stronger demand translates into higher operating profit.
At about 13.2× the published 2027 estimate, a C$0.40 EPS cut takes about C$5.30 off the stock even if the multiple holds. That is consistent with a roughly 2.5% decline from the reference close.
What to watch. Watch flagship comparable sales, retail gross margin excluding fuel, and normalized retail profit. Check promotions and one-time income before crediting an EPS beat.
Reference pricePublished earnings estimatesPrior quarterRelease schedule
Scoring the call
Measure the stock’s return from the close to the close, Toronto time.
Call locked , Toronto time.
Actual stock move +7.22%. The forecast missed by 9.72 percentage points. XIC moved -0.79% over the same window.
Retail comparable sales rose 3.2%, clearing the forecast’s 2% bull threshold. Retail gross margin excluding petroleum fell 16 basis points to 35.6%, and normalized retail pretax profit rose 2.9%. Normalized EPS rose 13.0% as Financial Services pretax profit rose 17.5% on a normalized basis and the share count fell. Canadian Tire now expects C$450–500 million in 2026 operating capital spending. The results support revisiting retail margin and capital spending assumptions. The effect on FY2027 earnings estimates remains unverified.
What changed
Comparable sales rose 3.2%, normalized diluted EPS rose 13% to C$4.27, and the annual dividend increased to C$7.30.
- Normalized diluted EPS
- Q3 2025 C$3.78
- Q3 2026 C$4.27
- Normalized retail pretax profit
- Q3 2025 C$192.4M
- Q3 2026 C$197.9M
- Normalized pretax profit · Financial Services
- Q3 2025 —
- Q3 2026 Up 17.5% year over year
- Retail gross margin excluding fuel
- Q3 2025 35.76%
- Q3 2026 35.60%
- Annual dividend per share
- Q3 2025 C$7.20
- Q3 2026 C$7.30
What the forecast missed
Comparable sales cleared the locked 2% bull threshold. The margin caution was directionally right, but sales and cost control still pushed normalized retail pretax profit up 2.9%. Financial Services grew 17.5% on the same basis. Normalized earnings attributable to shareholders rose from C$204.3M to C$219.6M, about 7.5%, and the lower share count helped lift per-share earnings 13%. These figures explain why the operating case beat our assumptions. The price move alone cannot identify how much each factor contributed.
What changed in the investment case
The stronger quarter improves the earnings starting point. At the Nov. 13 C$220.32 close, the preliminary five-year model yields 5.5% annualized versus 6.6% for XIC. The full equity report and valuation review are pending, including cash conversion and the capital it takes to sustain dividends and buybacks.
What we’re watching next Watch holiday comparable sales, the ex-fuel gross margin and credit losses. Reconcile full-year operating cash, retail capex and financial-services funding before setting a buy ceiling.
Five-year investment case
- TSX close · Nov 13, 2026
- C$220.32
- Base annualized · CTC.A / XIC
- 5.5% / 6.6%
- Bear case · five-year total
- -17.3%
- XIC break-even entry
- C$209.19
Preliminary event valuation. Conditional CAD returns, including distributions and modeled trading costs.
See the assumptions
The earnings anchor is C$14.66: C$10.19 normalized diluted EPS in the first nine months of 2026 plus C$4.47 in Q4 2025. Q4 2025 covered 14 weeks, so we also test a simple 13-week prorating. Bear, base and bull use annual EPS changes of −2%, +4% and +7%, with exit P/Es of 11×, 14× and 16×. These are conditional assumptions. The base multiple remains below the roughly 15× entry on the trailing earnings anchor. Dividends start at the declared C$7.30 run rate and grow 0%, 2% or 4% annually by case. No dividends are reinvested. XIC assumes 5% annual NAV growth and 1.97% annual distributions on opening capital, net of fund fees. Trading costs are 5 basis points each way for Canadian Tire and 3 each way for XIC.
Bear · -3.7% annualized
Year-five EPS C$13.25. Exit at 11× earnings.
C$145.77 exit price and C$36.50 cumulative dividends per share.
Base · 5.5% annualized
Year-five EPS C$17.84. Exit at 14× earnings.
C$249.71 exit price and C$37.99 cumulative dividends per share.
Bull · 10.8% annualized
Year-five EPS C$20.56. Exit at 16× earnings.
C$328.98 exit price and C$39.54 cumulative dividends per share.
- Base exit multiple falls from 14× to 13× · 4.1% annualized
- Base earnings growth slows from 4% to 3% · 4.6% annualized
- Illustrative 52-week earnings anchor · 5.1% annualized
TSX quoteQ3 2026 issuer releaseQ4 and FY2025 issuer releaseXIC fund information
What changed after Q3
The result supports a stronger earnings starting point than the pre-event retail thesis implied. After the price jump, headline EPS growth alone is insufficient to support adding. The valuation still needs to test whether retail cash flow can fund ongoing investment and whether finance income holds up through weaker consumer credit.