Scotiabank (TSX: BNS) — capital must earn its price
Decision at the November 19, 2026 close: Wait at C$123.44. Peralta estimates C$78.84 base fair value and a C$78 maximum entry price. This is an independent CAD forecast, not company guidance. December 2 FY2026/Q4 results are the next decision point.
- Market close (CAD)
- $123.44
- Bear fair value (CAD/share)
- $24.70
Company details
- Base fair value (CAD/share)
- $78.84
- Bull fair value (CAD/share)
- $121.59
- Maximum entry price (CAD/share)
- $78.00
- Base five-year BNS total return after trading costs
- +0.6% cumulative; +0.1% annualized
- Assumed five-year XIC NAV total return after trading costs
- +43.4% cumulative; +7.5% annualized
| Worksheet | Output |
|---|---|
| Five-year bank valuation | Saved five-year cases · Exact JSON |
| Independent bank calculator | Saved five-year cases and bank anchor |
The November 19 economics are unchanged from the first edition. This revision connects the saved results to the worksheet reader.
Scotiabank earns interest spread on Canadian and international deposits and loans, plus wealth, capital markets and transaction fees. Its international lending offers a wider margin and greater credit exposure than its Canadian franchise. In the Q3 2026 Report to Shareholders, Canadian Banking earned C$1.071 billion with 2.38% net interest margin and a 0.42% provision ratio; International Banking earned C$766 million with 4.69% margin and a 1.38% provision ratio (PDF pp. 23, 25). The valuation uses consolidated numbers and does not add segment earnings again.
For the quarter ended July 31, group net interest income was C$5.866 billion, group net interest margin 2.49% (2.36% a year earlier), noninterest income C$4.669 billion, operating expense C$5.556 billion, and credit-loss provision C$1.079 billion, an annualized 0.56% of average loans and acceptances. Loans were C$770.555 billion. Common equity was C$79.212 billion; the 1,218,811,654 common shares outstanding at July 31 reconcile to the reported C$64.99 book value per share. The 1,226 million diluted weighted-average shares used for quarterly EPS are a different measure. CET1 capital was C$64.508 billion on C$492.866 billion risk-weighted assets, or 13.1%. The quarterly common dividend was C$1.14. Q3 filing, PDF pp. 17–18, 52–53 and 80.
The reported CET1 minimum was 11.0% including domestic stability and systemic buffers, with approximately seven additional basis points of countercyclical buffer. Peralta's 12.5% distribution floor is a more cautious modeling assumption, not a claim about the legal minimum. Q3 capital discussion, PDF pp. 52–53.
The issuer's October 21 release expects C$96 million reported (C$104 million adjusted) Q4 KeyCorp earnings contribution after one-month-lag funding costs, and a C$55 million Chile deferred-tax-asset write-down that reduces both reported and adjusted Q4 earnings. Those are Q4 bridge items, not evidence of a lasting improvement in lending margin. The October 2 issuer release enlarged authorized repurchases from 15 million to 40 million shares through April 6, 2027; 13,044,315 shares had been purchased under the bid through August 31. Authorization is not a forecast of executed buybacks. The model includes no future repurchases or issuance and therefore retains any unspent capital in book value.
The CAD C$123.44 quote is the November 19 BNS.TO close captured in the approved market snapshot, cross-checked with dated TSX history. The financial statements stop at July 31; the gap to the November quote is a material timing limitation.
The worksheet annualizes Q3 as a starting run rate. Annualized C$23.464 billion net interest income divided by 2.49% margin implies C$942.3 billion earning assets. In each scenario, earning assets × forecast margin gives net interest income; fees less operating expenses give pre-provision profit; average loans × scenario provision rate gives credit losses. After scenario tax, C$0.70 billion of estimated annual preferred and noncontrolling claims is deducted for common earnings. The claim estimate and tax rates must be checked against FY2026 statements. The first 24 months recalculate through the existing independent bank-common-book-v1 calculator; the five-year extension carries forward its exact ending common book, CET1, RWA, dividends and fixed share count.
Common earnings increase book equity and CET1; dividends reduce both. The model caps distributions to preserve at least 12.5% CET1 on ending RWA. A dividend cut is therefore part of the bear result, not an undisclosed capital injection. The year-five terminal ROE is year-five forecast common earnings divided by average year-four and year-five common book, so retained capital must earn its terminal valuation. The justified terminal price/book multiple is (terminal ROE − perpetual growth) ÷ (cost of equity − perpetual growth). Cash dividends and terminal share price determine investor return; fair value discounts both at the scenario cost of equity. Amounts below are CAD and rounded; exact rows are in the output.
| Peralta case | Margin | Credit loss / loans | FY1 common earnings | FY5 CET1 | FY5 book/share | FY5 ROE | Terminal P/B | Terminal price | Fair value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | 2.25% | 1.00% | C$6.27bn | 12.50% | $72.10 | 5.01% | 0.32× | $22.87 | $24.70 |
| Base | 2.45% | 0.65% | C$10.58bn | 15.24% | $87.06 | 11.63% | 1.15× | $100.15 | $78.84 |
| Bull | 2.60% | 0.50% | C$13.13bn | 18.34% | $100.16 | 14.19% | 1.64× | $164.69 | $121.59 |
Base assumes 3% annual loan, earning-asset and fee growth, 3% expense growth, 4% RWA growth, a 25% tax rate and 2% planned dividend growth. Terminal growth is 3% and cost of equity 10.5%. Bear assumes 1% volume growth, 4% expense growth, a 26% tax rate, 2% terminal growth and 11.5% cost of equity. The FY2026 October balance sheet and Q4 earnings are not yet filed at this cutoff; the projection starts from July 31. No scenario should be read as management guidance.
At C$123.44, the fixed base cash-flow path would require about 18.0% terminal ROE to justify the quote with the same growth and discount rate. That is a price-implied condition, well above the model's 11.63% FY5 ROE. A lower cost of equity, sustainably stronger earnings or executed capital returns could change value, but require fresh evidence and explicit treatment of their CET1 effects.
At today's quote, the base case gives a C$100.15 terminal share price and C$24.21 of five-year cash dividends per starting share. After 10 basis points at entry and exit, modeled CAD total return is +0.6% cumulative, +0.1% annualized, before personal tax and without dividend reinvestment. The bear case gives a C$22.87 terminal price and C$14.77 dividends, with the capital floor forcing annual dividends down to about C$1.53 per share by year five: −69.6% five-year after-cost total return. Its C$24.70 present fair value is a separate discounted-value measure, 80.0% below the quote.
XIC is modeled at a Peralta assumption of 7.5% annual CAD NAV total return with distributions reinvested, plus five basis points each for entry and exit: +43.4% cumulative, +7.5% annualized over five years. This is a comparison assumption, not an externally forecast return. BlackRock's October 2026 XIC factsheet reports CAD denomination, quarterly distributions, 0.05% management fee and 0.06% historical MER. NAV total return already reflects fund expenses, so the MER is not deducted again. BNS trails the assumed XIC return by 42.9 percentage points cumulatively and 7.4 annual points.
Under the base case, the price that would beat XIC by two annual percentage points is C$78.93. Fair value is C$78.84; rounding the lower threshold down to a whole dollar gives a C$78 maximum entry price. It is an underwriting ceiling, not a standing trade instruction; both model and quote need refreshing before use.
The issuer calendar sets FY2026/Q4 results for December 2. Reconsider the call if the bank shows Q4 group margin at or above 2.49%, annualized provision rate at or below 0.60% of average loans, and CET1 at or above 13.0% after actual distributions, with a credible FY2027 bridge to materially higher common earnings. Separate the stated C$96 million KeyCorp contribution and C$55 million Chile tax charge, and reconcile actual repurchases and end-period shares to book/share. These one-quarter screens alone cannot close the price gap: a model at this quote needs roughly 18% sustainable terminal ROE or a separately funded, CET1-safe capital-return bridge. Margin below 2.40%, provision rate above 0.75%, or CET1 below 12.5% would increase bear-case weight. These are Peralta review thresholds, not Scotiabank guidance.
The source ledger identifies dated issuer filings, issuer notices, the quote and fund factsheet. The original Q3 PDF is retained in the owner-only package; its publisher link is public. The input packet, bank calculator, five-year worksheet and frozen output let readers reproduce the case arithmetic without network access. Forecast margins, credit losses, tax, growth, trading costs, XIC return and terminal multiples are Peralta assumptions. The July-to-November balance-sheet gap and possible Q4 share changes may materially alter results.