Scotiabank (TSX: BNS) — capital must earn its price

Wait at the November 19, 2026 TSX close of C$123.44. The Bank of Nova Scotia is a Canadian bank in the Financials sector and Diversified Banks industry. Peralta estimates C$78.84 in base fair value and a C$78 maximum entry in Canadian dollars. The next review is FY2026/Q4 results on December 2, 2026. The financial baseline is July 31, 2026. For new Canadian equity capital, prefer XIC at this close. Base five-year annualized CAD total return after trading costs is 0.15% for BNS versus 7.48% for XIC, a 7.32 percentage point gap before rounding.

Stock Price History

Market close (CAD)
$123.44
Bear fair value (CAD/share)
$24.70
Company details
Base fair value (CAD/share)
$78.84
Bull fair value (CAD/share)
$121.59
Maximum entry price (CAD/share)
$78.00
Bear five-year total return at entry, after trading costs
-57.4%
Base five-year BNS total return after trading costs
+0.8% cumulative, +0.15% annualized
Assumed five-year XIC NAV total return after trading costs
+43.4% cumulative, +7.48% annualized

Stock Price History

Investment Thesis

The Canadian deposit franchise and international loan spreads support meaningful earnings, but capital retained past the dividend must earn an adequate return. Peralta's base case earns 11.63% on average common equity by year five and ends with 15.24% CET1. That combination leaves a stronger capital buffer and an undemanding 1.15× terminal book multiple. At C$123.44, the investor pays for much higher earning power.

Market Mispricing

The close is 1.90× July common book. The same base dividends, book, 10.5% discount rate and 3% terminal growth require 17.96% terminal ROE to justify the close. Q3 actual ROE was 14.1%. Even the bull case, with a 14.19% modeled terminal ROE and a lower discount rate, values the shares at C$121.59. Q3 financial highlights

Recent Developments

On October 21, Scotiabank estimated C$96 million reported and C$104 million adjusted Q4 KeyCorp earnings contribution after funding costs, and announced a C$55 million Chile deferred-tax asset write-down that reduces both reported and adjusted earnings. On October 2, it widened the normal-course bid from 15 million to 40 million shares through April 6, 2027. It had bought 13,044,315 shares under the bid through August 31. Future execution could lower the share count and CET1. KeyCorp and Chile notice · Repurchase amendment

Earnings Outlook

Q3 reported common earnings were C$2.78 billion and Q3 adjusted common earnings were C$2.80 billion. The base first forecast year produces C$10.58 billion, with 2.45% consolidated margin and 65 basis points of credit losses. A cleaner quarter supports normalization, while the forecast allows credit cost to exceed Q3's 56 basis points. Q3 results and adjustments

Valuation Summary

The five-year model discounts feasible common dividends and the terminal value of common book. Base present value is C$18.05 of dividends plus C$60.79 of terminal share value. Base annualized CAD return is 0.15% at the close with dividends reinvested and after trading costs. XIC returns 7.48% on Peralta’s assumed NAV path over the same five years.

Recommended Action and Entry Price

Wait. Base fair value of C$78.84 is below the C$82.08 price that clears XIC by two annual percentage points. Rounding fair value down sets the C$78 entry. A buyer at C$78 faces a modeled 57.4% five-year bear loss with dividends reinvested and after costs.

Catalysts

Use the December 2 earnings release to test whether group margin holds at least 2.49%, annualized provisions stay at or below 60 basis points, and CET1 remains at least 13.0% after distributions. Reconcile the FY2027 earnings outlook, actual shares and common book before revising the price. At this price, the base capital and payout path needs roughly 18% sustainable common ROE to clear both valuation and return requirements. One quarter at the operating screens would warrant updating the model with FY2027 guidance and realized capital actions.

Primary Risks to Thesis

Deposit repricing and international delinquencies can squeeze earnings from both ends. A lower regulatory capital need or an accretive capital return could strengthen the upside, while repurchases above book consume CET1 and mechanically reduce book per remaining share. A 12.5% modeled distribution floor restricts bear-case payouts.

Closing Prices

Selected TSX sessions, in CAD, through November 19. Prices are unadjusted closes. The final point is the approved market snapshot used in valuation. Historical quote series

DateClose (CAD)Maximum entry (CAD)
2026-08-20119.36
2026-08-25128.73
2026-08-31126.87
2026-09-11129.63
2026-09-18131.63
2026-09-25132.34
2026-10-02129.93
2026-10-16129.52
2026-10-23130.00
2026-10-30131.05
2026-11-04134.50
2026-11-06129.54
2026-11-13131.85
2026-11-17127.43
2026-11-19123.4478.00