Scotiabank (TSX: BNS) — capital must earn its price
Wait at the November 19, 2026 TSX close of C$123.44. The Bank of Nova Scotia is a Canadian bank in the Financials sector and Diversified Banks industry. Peralta estimates C$78.84 in base fair value and a C$78 maximum entry in Canadian dollars. The next review is FY2026/Q4 results on December 2, 2026. The financial baseline is July 31, 2026. For new Canadian equity capital, prefer XIC at this close. Base five-year annualized CAD total return after trading costs is 0.15% for BNS versus 7.48% for XIC, a 7.32 percentage point gap before rounding.
- Market close (CAD)
- $123.44
- Bear fair value (CAD/share)
- $24.70
Company details
- Base fair value (CAD/share)
- $78.84
- Bull fair value (CAD/share)
- $121.59
- Maximum entry price (CAD/share)
- $78.00
- Bear five-year total return at entry, after trading costs
- -57.4%
- Base five-year BNS total return after trading costs
- +0.8% cumulative, +0.15% annualized
- Assumed five-year XIC NAV total return after trading costs
- +43.4% cumulative, +7.48% annualized
Investment Thesis
The Canadian deposit franchise and international loan spreads support meaningful earnings, but capital retained past the dividend must earn an adequate return. Peralta's base case earns 11.63% on average common equity by year five and ends with 15.24% CET1. That combination leaves a stronger capital buffer and an undemanding 1.15× terminal book multiple. At C$123.44, the investor pays for much higher earning power.
Market Mispricing
The close is 1.90× July common book. The same base dividends, book, 10.5% discount rate and 3% terminal growth require 17.96% terminal ROE to justify the close. Q3 actual ROE was 14.1%. Even the bull case, with a 14.19% modeled terminal ROE and a lower discount rate, values the shares at C$121.59. Q3 financial highlights
Recent Developments
On October 21, Scotiabank estimated C$96 million reported and C$104 million adjusted Q4 KeyCorp earnings contribution after funding costs, and announced a C$55 million Chile deferred-tax asset write-down that reduces both reported and adjusted earnings. On October 2, it widened the normal-course bid from 15 million to 40 million shares through April 6, 2027. It had bought 13,044,315 shares under the bid through August 31. Future execution could lower the share count and CET1. KeyCorp and Chile notice · Repurchase amendment
Earnings Outlook
Q3 reported common earnings were C$2.78 billion and Q3 adjusted common earnings were C$2.80 billion. The base first forecast year produces C$10.58 billion, with 2.45% consolidated margin and 65 basis points of credit losses. A cleaner quarter supports normalization, while the forecast allows credit cost to exceed Q3's 56 basis points. Q3 results and adjustments
Valuation Summary
The five-year model discounts feasible common dividends and the terminal value of common book. Base present value is C$18.05 of dividends plus C$60.79 of terminal share value. Base annualized CAD return is 0.15% at the close with dividends reinvested and after trading costs. XIC returns 7.48% on Peralta’s assumed NAV path over the same five years.
Recommended Action and Entry Price
Wait. Base fair value of C$78.84 is below the C$82.08 price that clears XIC by two annual percentage points. Rounding fair value down sets the C$78 entry. A buyer at C$78 faces a modeled 57.4% five-year bear loss with dividends reinvested and after costs.
Catalysts
Use the December 2 earnings release to test whether group margin holds at least 2.49%, annualized provisions stay at or below 60 basis points, and CET1 remains at least 13.0% after distributions. Reconcile the FY2027 earnings outlook, actual shares and common book before revising the price. At this price, the base capital and payout path needs roughly 18% sustainable common ROE to clear both valuation and return requirements. One quarter at the operating screens would warrant updating the model with FY2027 guidance and realized capital actions.
Primary Risks to Thesis
Deposit repricing and international delinquencies can squeeze earnings from both ends. A lower regulatory capital need or an accretive capital return could strengthen the upside, while repurchases above book consume CET1 and mechanically reduce book per remaining share. A 12.5% modeled distribution floor restricts bear-case payouts.
Closing Prices
Selected TSX sessions, in CAD, through November 19. Prices are unadjusted closes. The final point is the approved market snapshot used in valuation. Historical quote series
| Date | Close (CAD) | Maximum entry (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-20 | 119.36 | |
| 2026-08-25 | 128.73 | |
| 2026-08-31 | 126.87 | |
| 2026-09-11 | 129.63 | |
| 2026-09-18 | 131.63 | |
| 2026-09-25 | 132.34 | |
| 2026-10-02 | 129.93 | |
| 2026-10-16 | 129.52 | |
| 2026-10-23 | 130.00 | |
| 2026-10-30 | 131.05 | |
| 2026-11-04 | 134.50 | |
| 2026-11-06 | 129.54 | |
| 2026-11-13 | 131.85 | |
| 2026-11-17 | 127.43 | |
| 2026-11-19 | 123.44 | 78.00 |
Company Overview
Scotiabank is a Canadian chartered bank with four operating segments and an Other category that includes treasury, centrally managed items, associated-company income and eliminations. The quarter ended July 31, 2026 reconciles below in C$ millions. Business segment review, Q3 pp. 8 and 22–34
| Q3 FY2026 reported | Revenue | Net income | Common earnings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Canadian Banking | 3,646 | 1,071 | 1,071 |
| International Banking | 2,948 | 766 | 725 |
| Global Wealth Management | 1,897 | 518 | 515 |
| Global Banking and Markets | 2,014 | 647 | 647 |
| Other and eliminations | 30 | (49) | (180) |
| Consolidated | 10,535 | 2,953 | 2,778 |
Products and Services
Canadian and international banking serve consumers and businesses with deposit accounts, mortgages, personal credit and commercial lending. Wealth earns advisory, brokerage and asset-management fees. Global Banking and Markets supplies corporate lending, underwriting, advisory, trading and hedging. FY2025 annual report, business lines
Business Model
Deposits and wholesale liabilities fund loans, securities and other earning assets. The interest spread depends on asset repricing versus funding costs. Transaction, wealth and dealer fees diversify revenue, with some dealer income and associated-company earnings reported in non-interest income. The four segments and Other above consolidate to the group driver totals, which the valuation uses once.
Revenue Drivers
Q3 interest income after funding cost was C$5.87 billion, 56% of revenue. Canadian Banking's 2.38% margin and 42 bps of provisions compare with International's 4.69% margin and 138 bps, using the issuer's segment definitions. Wealth reported C$473.9 billion of group assets under management and CAD wealth revenue of C$1.90 billion. Capital Markets reported C$2.01 billion of revenue, up from C$1.53 billion a year earlier. Q3 financial highlights and segment results
Cost Structure
The quarter incurred C$5.56 billion of non-interest expense and C$1.08 billion of credit provisions. Compensation, technology, premises and compliance contribute to the expense base. Dealer and wealth compensation responds to fee and transaction activity. Interest expense is netted into net interest income. Q3 consolidated income statement
Operating Levers
At the model's C$942.3 billion starting earning-asset base, 10 bps of margin represents roughly C$942 million of annual pre-tax revenue before volume shifts. A 10 bp provision increase on about C$771 billion of net loans represents C$771 million of annual pre-tax cost at constant balances. These exposures explain why spread and losses drive the range of modeled common earnings.
Distribution
Physical branches and advisers support acquisition and service. Scotia and Tangerine's digital channels serve customers who prefer remote onboarding and self-service. The bank reported 1,984 branches and offices at July 31, down from 2,135 a year earlier. The multichannel model can retain transaction deposits, but IT and fraud controls require ongoing spend. Q3 financial highlights · FY2025 business lines
Geographic Exposure
Canada was C$6.07 billion or 57.6% of Q3 revenue. The U.S. contributed C$950 million, Mexico C$1.04 billion, Peru C$529 million, Chile C$693 million, Caribbean C$740 million and Other C$510 million. FX translation and regional credit can affect reported CAD growth. The July consolidated base reflects divestitures completed before the quarter. Q3 geographic highlights, table T16
Regulatory Environment
OSFI reduced the Domestic Stability Buffer to 3.0% effective June 19, 2026. The bank reported an 11.0% CET1 requirement before approximately seven basis points of bank-specific countercyclical buffer. Capital, liquidity and local host-country rules constrain distribution and cross-border transfers. Peralta uses a 12.5% CET1 distribution floor. OSFI buffer decision · Q3 capital management
Industry Structure
Canada's large universal banks combine insured retail deposits, wholesale funding, advice and corporate finance. The Competition Bureau estimated that the six largest banks could account for up to 90% of Canadian personal transaction accounts in its RBC–HSBC Canada review. Distribution access, brand and operating scale support deposit gathering. Competition Bureau report
Growth and Cyclicality
Mortgage and commercial loan origination follow housing turnover, rates and business demand. Lower rates can help borrowers and also compress spreads where assets reprice faster than deposits. Reported gross impaired loans rose to 1.00% of loans and acceptances in Q3 from 0.90% a year earlier even as quarterly net interest margin improved. The base 65 bps credit loss provision sits above Q3's 56 bps. Q3 financial highlights
Competitors
RBC competes in Canadian banking, wealth and dealer activity, with stronger Q3 common ROE. BMO shares the wholesale and cross-border business model and is useful for separating recurring operating performance from disposition charges. In International Banking, local lenders compete on customer relationships, payments and local-currency deposit pricing. RBC Q3 · BMO Q3
Market Share
The Competition Bureau found the four largest firms could exceed 65% of several overlapping products in certain Canadian markets. Its industry figures describe product concentration and are distinct from an individual Scotiabank share. Scotiabank's July report discloses segment and geographic economics, but supplies no consistently defined current company-by-product market-share denominator across these geographies. Peralta therefore tests growth with actual originations and deposits, without assuming share gains. Competition Bureau report · Q3 segment and geography disclosures
Competitive Advantages
Existing transaction clients give Scotiabank opportunities to gather deposits and cross-sell lending and advice. International banking creates a wider net interest margin. The 96 bp Q3 gap in provision ratios between international and Canadian banking ate into the 231 bp spread difference before considering operating expense and capital. Q3 segments
Pricing and Cost Position
Canada's franchise funding and the higher-yield international loan mix buffer the cost of wholesale issuance. Consolidated reported expense was 52.7% of revenue in Q3, versus 53.7% a year earlier. The base case grows both fees and expenses at 3%, so the underwriting does not assume a persistent productivity windfall. Q3 financial highlights
Entry Barriers and Substitutes
Capital, deposit access, compliance and transaction infrastructure make a national full-service bank difficult to replicate. Credit unions, mortgage brokers, digital banks and fintechs can compete in individual products. Losing deposits to app-based competitors or rate shoppers would raise funding costs even if loan balances held up. Competition Bureau report
Supplier and Customer Dynamics
Households and corporate depositors are funding suppliers as well as revenue clients. Loan borrowers can shop renewals, and large corporate clients can use capital markets or competing lenders. A net shift from demand to rate-sensitive deposits matters to modeled NIM. The quarter's C$1.006 trillion deposit balance is the comparison point for Q4 funding composition. Q3 consolidated financial position
Regulation and Structural Risks
A wider bank buffer, different risk weights or restrictions at overseas subsidiaries could reduce distributable capital without an immediate income decline. Canadian and international deposit, conduct and capital rules can raise the ongoing cost of serving customers. A 100 bp increase in the floor at the July RWA base would consume approximately C$4.93 billion of modeled distribution headroom. Q3 capital management
Historical Performance
FY2024 to FY2025 revenue rose 12.1% to C$37.74 billion, but common earnings held near C$7.28 billion. The nine months ended July 2026 had C$7.40 billion of common earnings versus C$5.18 billion a year earlier, aided by the absence of a prior-year disposal impairment. The trailing common earnings improvement to C$9.50 billion is a better starting comparison than FY2025 alone. Annual income statement · Q3 income statement
Income Statement Analysis
Quarterly revenue rose 11.1% year over year and non-interest expense rose 9.2%. C$373 million higher net interest income and C$676 million higher non-interest income drove the revenue change. From Q2 to Q3 2026, provisions fell from C$1.22 billion to C$1.08 billion while NIM stayed at 2.49%. Q3 consolidated results
Balance Sheet Analysis
Net loans ended July at C$770.6 billion, near October's C$771.0 billion, and deposits grew C$39.7 billion to C$1.006 trillion. RWA rose from C$474.5 billion to C$492.9 billion. CET1 grew in dollars to C$64.5 billion but the ratio declined to 13.1% as RWA, divestiture effects, FX and distributions moved the denominator and numerator. Q3 financial position and capital
Cash Flow Analysis
Operating cash outflow of C$16.81 billion in Q3 followed a C$4.38 billion inflow in the same quarter a year earlier. The quarter's investing inflow was C$19.05 billion. Changes in secured financing, trading assets, loans and deposits cause wide movements. The five-year model uses after-tax common earnings, capital retained and feasible dividends to represent the shareholder claim. Q3 cash flows
Earnings Quality
Q3 reported common earnings of C$2.778 billion were C$20 million below adjusted. Nine-month reported common earnings of C$7.401 billion were C$426 million below adjusted. The nine-month C$17.0 billion of net interest income is the more repeatable core. Trading results and earnings from associates need separate review on the next print, even though the forecast uses a consolidated non-interest-income line. Q3 reported and adjusted results
Nonrecurring Items
FY2025 recorded a C$1.365 billion impairment tied to the announced sale of operations in Colombia, Costa Rica and Panama. Q1 FY2026 recognized a further C$423 million loss when that transfer closed. The October Chile tax notice represents a further discrete earnings item, while the KeyCorp update is one quarter of an ongoing investment contribution. The July-quarter starting run rate leaves the Q1 and FY2025 losses outside annualized operating lines. Scotiabank completed its purchase of the remaining Scotia Group Jamaica shares on October 30. Reconcile paid consideration, non-controlling interests, common book and regulatory capital to the Q4 notes before reflecting the acquisition in per-share earnings or CET1. Jamaica completion Q3 Other segment and divestitures · Issuer October notice
Funding and Cash Conversion
July net loans were 76.6% of reported deposits, versus 79.8% in October. Collateral, wholesale borrowing and deposits fund the asset base and carry liquidity obligations. LCR was 126% and NSFR 116% in July. Q3 common dividends were C$1.14 per share, while the cash flow statement records C$1.011 billion of cash repurchases. Note 10 records approximately 8.6 million shares cancelled at an average C$116.89, with C$1.031 billion total including tax. Q3 financial highlights · Cash flow and shares
Key Ratios
| Reported comparison | Q3 FY2025 | Q2 FY2026 | Q3 FY2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Return on common equity | 12.2% | 13.1% | 14.1% |
| Net interest margin | 2.36% | 2.49% | 2.49% |
| Provision ratio, annualized | 0.55% | 0.66% | 0.56% |
| Expense / revenue | 53.7% | 52.8% | 52.7% |
| CET1 ratio | 13.3% | 13.3% | 13.1% |
| Common book per share (CAD) | 60.57 | 62.95 | 64.99 |
Source: Q3 financial highlights
Forward Outlook
Base year-one common earnings of C$10.58 billion are about 11% above the trailing C$9.50 billion as the starting run rate replaces the prior-year and first-quarter unusual items. The first forecast year's modeled dividend of C$4.65 per share is about 54% of common earnings. Review Q4's actual deposit and expense trends before accepting this earnings increment.
Model Choice
A regulated bank's liabilities largely fund its operating assets. Peralta values common shares directly through feasible dividends and terminal common equity. The governed 24-month bank-common-book-v1 calculation fixes the first two forecast years and validates capital and book. The three-year extension carries their ending balances into year five.
Growth
The model uses C$5.866 billion of July-quarter NII divided by 2.49%, annualized, to infer C$942.3 billion of earning assets. C$18.68 billion of non-interest income is annualized from C$4.669 billion. At base, earning assets, loans and consolidated fees each grow 3%. Canadian and international loan/deposit growth feed group net interest income, while wealth and dealer activity feed fees and associated-company contributions through Other. The model has consolidated assumptions because the filing does not give forward segment-level NIM, expense and FX paths. That limits attribution and makes the segment data a checkpoint for the December re-underwrite. Q3 segment review
Profitability
Base NIM of 2.45% gives C$23.78 billion of year-one NII. Add C$19.24 billion of modeled non-interest income, subtract C$22.89 billion of expenses and C$5.08 billion of credit losses (65 bps of C$782.03 billion of average loans). At 25% tax and after C$0.70 billion of estimated annual preferred and minority claims, common earnings are C$10.58 billion. Q3 reported non-controlling income and preferred/other claims total C$175 million, roughly C$0.70 billion annualized. The fixed claim is a modeling simplification. Q3 statements
Reinvestment or Required Capital
Base RWA rises 4% annually from C$492.87 billion to C$599.65 billion. That C$106.78 billion growth requires C$13.35 billion of cumulative additional CET1 at the 12.5% distribution floor. The model adds common income and subtracts distributions from book and CET1, with year-one base dividends of C$5.67 billion. Starting CET1 C$64.51 billion is C$2.90 billion above the modeled floor. Common dividends can be cut to maintain the floor. Changes in risk weights, regulatory deductions, FX and OCI could alter realized headroom independently of earnings. Capital note and CET1 continuity
Discount Rate
Use a 10.5% nominal CAD base cost of equity against the Bank of Canada's November 18 10-year benchmark of 3.80%. The 6.70-point residual is a Peralta equity premium including Scotiabank-specific credit, geographic and execution risk. The 9.5% and 11.5% alternatives hold the base operating cash flows fixed and recalculate terminal value and the price hurdle. Bank of Canada dated bond series
| Cost of equity | Base fair value (CAD) | XIC plus 2 points ceiling (CAD) | Rounded maximum entry (CAD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.5% | $91.93 | $91.84 | $91.00 |
| 10.5% | $78.84 | $82.08 | $78.00 |
| 11.5% | $68.87 | $74.63 | $68.00 |
Terminal Economics
Year-five common earnings of C$12.00 billion divided by average year-four and year-five common book imply 11.63% sustainable ROE. With 3% perpetual growth and a 10.5% cost of equity, justified terminal P/B is (11.63% − 3%) ÷ (10.5% − 3%), or 1.15×. Sustainable growth of 3% at that ROE requires retention of approximately 26% of terminal earnings. The terminal formula credits future distributable value subject to those economics, while the five explicit years use the modeled dividend policy and capital floor.
Bridge to One Common Share
C$79.212 billion common book divided by the verified 1.218812 billion period-end common shares reconciles to C$64.99 per share. The issuer recorded 1.226 billion Q3 diluted weighted-average shares for EPS. The model keeps period-end shares fixed, preventing a forward buyback benefit from entering without a cash cost. Substituting the 1.226 billion quarterly diluted count into the same aggregate economics would lower base value to about C$78.38. At year five, C$87.06 modeled book per share times 1.15× gives a C$100.15 terminal price. Discounting it produces C$60.79, plus C$18.05 present dividends gives C$78.84. Highlighted July capital and share reconciliation · Q3 original
| Case | Fair value/share | Terminal price/share | Five-year after-cost total return | FY5 CET1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | C$24.70 | C$22.87 | -69.56% | 12.50% |
| Base | C$78.84 | C$100.15 | +0.56% | 15.24% |
| Bull | C$121.59 | C$164.69 | +53.94% | 18.34% |
Bear annual bridge
| Year | Net interest income | Credit losses | Common earnings | Dividend/share | End CET1 | Book/share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 21,414.4 | 7,744.0 | 6,271.0 | C$4.56 | 12.79% | C$65.58 |
| 2 | 21,628.6 | 7,821.4 | 5,827.6 | C$4.10 | 12.51% | C$66.26 |
| 3 | 21,844.9 | 7,899.6 | 5,359.2 | C$2.55 | 12.50% | C$68.11 |
| 4 | 22,063.3 | 7,978.6 | 4,864.8 | C$2.03 | 12.50% | C$70.07 |
| 5 | 22,283.9 | 8,058.4 | 4,343.3 | C$1.53 | 12.50% | C$72.10 |
Base annual bridge
| Year | Net interest income | Credit losses | Common earnings | Dividend/share | End CET1 | Book/share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 23,779.7 | 5,083.2 | 10,581.5 | C$4.65 | 13.54% | C$69.02 |
| 2 | 24,493.1 | 5,235.7 | 10,920.0 | C$4.74 | 13.99% | C$73.24 |
| 3 | 25,227.9 | 5,392.7 | 11,268.6 | C$4.84 | 14.42% | C$77.64 |
| 4 | 25,984.7 | 5,554.5 | 11,627.6 | C$4.94 | 14.84% | C$82.25 |
| 5 | 26,764.2 | 5,721.2 | 11,997.5 | C$5.03 | 15.24% | C$87.06 |
Bull annual bridge
| Year | Net interest income | Credit losses | Common earnings | Dividend/share | End CET1 | Book/share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 25,480.6 | 3,929.1 | 13,128.2 | C$4.74 | 14.09% | C$71.02 |
| 2 | 26,499.8 | 4,086.2 | 13,941.0 | C$4.93 | 15.11% | C$77.53 |
| 3 | 27,559.8 | 4,249.7 | 14,792.8 | C$5.13 | 16.16% | C$84.53 |
| 4 | 28,662.2 | 4,419.7 | 15,685.3 | C$5.33 | 17.24% | C$92.07 |
| 5 | 29,808.7 | 4,596.5 | 16,620.4 | C$5.55 | 18.34% | C$100.16 |
Price-Implied Expectations
Keeping the base dividend stream, year-five book, 3% growth and 10.5% equity discount rate fixed, the price implies a terminal P/B near 2.00× and terminal ROE of 17.96%. On average FY4/FY5 common book of roughly C$103.17 billion, that implies about C$18.53 billion of sustainable annual common earnings versus C$12.00 billion in the base forecast. This solves one variable and does not represent consensus.
Independent Cross-Check
Apply the peer-based economic framework directly to current common book as a through-cycle check. At Scotiabank's July reported ROE of 14.1%, 10.5% cost of equity and 3% growth, the justified current P/B is 1.48× or about C$96.19 per share. Even using a whole quarter's stronger reported ROE across the cycle, this check remains C$27.25 below the close. RBC earns more on common equity and trades at about 2.79× July book. Its trading multiple embeds its own growth and risk, so it is an upper comparison rather than a BNS mark.
Conclusion and Change from Prior Edition
Base fair value remains C$78.84 and maximum entry C$78, a C$0.00 change for both from the prior November 19 edition. New diagnostics quantify the 100 bp discount-rate sensitivity, entry-date downside and reported-peer economics. The July financial date, November close, input packet, calculator and bank valuation are retained.
Peer Selection
RBC represents a higher-return Canadian universal bank with material wealth and capital markets operations. BMO provides a Canadian and U.S. cross-border comparison with similar business categories. Each uses a TSX CAD quote and July 31 quarter denominators. RBC Q3 · BMO Q3
Dated Ratio Table
November 19, 2026 close and July 31, 2026 denominators. P/B is close divided by book per common share. ROE is reported or issuer-adjusted Q3 common income over average common equity, annualized as disclosed. CET1 uses regulatory capital over RWA.
| Bank | Nov 19 close (CAD) | Jul 31 book/share (CAD) | P/B | Jul 31 reported ROE | Jul 31 adjusted ROE | Jul 31 CET1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BNS | 123.44 | 64.99 | 1.90× | 14.1% | 14.2% | 13.1% |
| RY | 269.45 | 96.73 | 2.79× | 17.9% | 18.1% | 13.5% |
| BMO | 231.08 | 113.06 | 2.04× | 8.4% | 14.0% | 13.0% |
BNS Q3 highlights · RBC Q3 highlights · BMO Q3 financial summary · BNS market data · RY market data · BMO market data
Comparability Adjustments
RBC's C$96.73 book/share is calculated from C$133.922 billion in common equity and 1.384554 billion period-end shares. BMO's 8.4% reported ROE includes a C$973 million after-tax Q3 divestiture charge and is 14.0% on the issuer's adjusted basis. Adjusted ROEs show the effect of those choices, with issuer-specific exclusions. Consolidated mortgage and international mix, wealth fee exposure and risk-weight rules differ across the group. No FX conversion was necessary.
Implications for Value
Scotiabank trades below RBC's P/B and below BMO's despite a similar adjusted Q3 ROE to BMO. A discount to these peers supports a relative case only if July's comparable earnings persist. At the close Scotiabank still needs 17.96% terminal ROE under its own base conditions. The peer discount therefore fails to provide the required return on our underwriting.
Bear Case
Lending, earning assets and fees grow 1%, expense grows 4%, group margin falls to 2.25% and annual credit losses reach 100 bps. RWA grows 3.5%, tax is 26%, terminal growth 2% and cost of equity 11.5%. Driven by weaker earnings and the 12.5% floor, annual common dividends decline to C$1.53 by year five. A combination of international impairment and Canadian funding repricing would make this path more plausible.
Base Case
Group NIM settles at 2.45%, provisions at 65 bps, and expenses rise 3% with assets and fees. RWA grows 4% and dividends target 2% annual growth. By year five CET1 is 15.24%, but the C$100.15 terminal price and reinvested dividends imply only about 0.8% cumulative total return after costs at the close. The proprietary hurdle requires materially better economics or a lower starting price.
Bull Case
Deposit costs ease relative to asset yields and loan performance improves, allowing 2.60% NIM, 50 bps credit losses and 4% annual asset, loan and fee growth with 2.5% expense growth. Year-five CET1 rises to 18.34% and common ROE to 14.19%. At the governed lower discount rate of 10.0% and 3.5% terminal growth, fair value is C$121.59. The bull-case positive holding return still relies on higher projected share value and dividends five years forward.
Outcomes at Close and Entry
“Value vs.” compares present fair value with the acquisition price. The five-year return reinvests BNS distributions in fractional BNS shares at each modeled year-end ex-dividend price, with a 10 bp initial entry charge, a 10 bp exit charge on the final position and zero incremental reinvestment fees. XIC assumes reinvested NAV total return in CAD at 7.5% per year, plus 5 bp each to enter and exit. Both returns are before personal tax. That is +43.4% over five years after costs. BlackRock reports a 0.05% management fee, 0.06% historical MER and quarterly distributions. NAV returns already incorporate operating expenses. BlackRock October 2026 XIC factsheet
| Case | Fair value (CAD/share) | Value vs. close | Value vs. entry | After-cost five-year return at close | After-cost five-year return at entry |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | $24.70 | -80.0% | -68.3% | -74.7% | -57.4% |
| Base | $78.84 | -36.1% | +1.1% | +0.8% | +66.4% |
| Bull | $121.59 | -1.5% | +55.9% | +58.2% | +159.5% |
At the November 19, 2026 close, each price test uses the lower of discounted fair value and the price that clears the applicable XIC return by two annual points, rounded down to a whole CAD dollar.
| Assumption | Close | Fair value | Maximum entry | Price rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | $123.44 | $78.84 | $78.00 | Wait |
| Lower cost of equity (9.5%) | $123.44 | $91.93 | $91.00 | Wait |
| Higher cost of equity (11.5%) | $123.44 | $68.87 | $68.00 | Wait |
| Bull bank operating and terminal assumptions | $123.44 | $121.59 | $121.00 | Wait |
| XIC multiple compression | $123.44 | $78.84 | $78.00 | Wait |
The bank bull case is the strongest alternative. It assumes 2.60% net interest margin, 50 bps provisions and 10.0% cost of equity. Those operating assumptions jointly improve on the Q3 group margin of 2.49% and disclosed provision ratio of 56 bps. It beats XIC by 2.12 annual percentage points, but its C$121 entry remains below the C$123.44 close because of the fair-value requirement. The decision stays at Wait. The discount-rate sensitivities keep annual operating cash flows fixed and reprice both fair value and terminal proceeds. Scotiabank Q3 results
| Bank scenario | BNS annualized | XIC annualized | BNS less XIC | BNS cash-dividend control |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | -24.03% | +7.48% | -31.51 pp | -21.17% |
| Base | +0.15% | +7.48% | -7.32 pp | +0.11% |
| Bull | +9.60% | +7.48% | +2.12 pp | +9.01% |
Each reinvestment price starts with the value at that year-end of remaining dividends and the terminal share price, discounted at the scenario cost of equity. Multiply that ex-dividend value by the ratio of purchase price to initial fair value raised to the proportion of the five-year period remaining. The starting premium or discount thus fades geometrically to zero by year five. At the close, the base path runs from C$118.05 in year one to C$100.15 at exit and one initial share grows to 1.2446 shares. Actual dividend dates and prices will differ, and the terminal convergence assumption affects modeled reinvestment returns. The cash-dividend column is the predecessor’s return convention for comparison.
| Year | Bear ex-dividend price | Base ex-dividend price | Bull ex-dividend price | Bear shares | Base shares | Bull shares |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $83.24 | $118.05 | $130.57 | 1.0548 | 1.0394 | 1.0363 |
| 2 | $56.51 | $113.04 | $138.22 | 1.1313 | 1.0830 | 1.0733 |
| 3 | $40.82 | $108.41 | $146.42 | 1.2019 | 1.1314 | 1.1109 |
| 4 | $30.19 | $104.12 | $155.23 | 1.2827 | 1.1850 | 1.1491 |
| 5 | $22.87 | $100.15 | $164.69 | 1.3687 | 1.2446 | 1.1878 |
An independent ETF cross-check starts from BlackRock’s October 31 portfolio P/E of 21.48x and net distribution yield of 2.00%. At 5.5% nominal earnings growth and a flat exit multiple, annualizing price growth and reinvesting a constant yield produces 7.59% after ETF trading costs. The growth and exit multiples are Peralta scenarios. The calculation uses a net distribution yield and applies the fund’s trading costs without deducting its MER again. With 4% earnings growth and an 18x exit multiple, XIC returns 2.38% and still leads the BNS base. XIC already held 3.15% in Scotiabank at October 31, giving index investors measured exposure without a separate position. BlackRock October factsheet
| XIC cross-check | Annual EPS growth | Exit P/E | After-cost annual return |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multiple compression | 4.0% | 18.00x | +2.38% |
| Flat multiple | 5.5% | 21.48x | +7.59% |
| Multiple expansion | 7.0% | 24.00x | +11.57% |
Market-Implied Case
The close is 56.6% above base value and 1.5% above bull value. With the base dividend and equity path held fixed, the stock needs near 18% terminal ROE. At fixed annual dividends, year-five book and terminal cost of equity, the close needs C$173.63 of year-five share value for discounted fair value to cover the purchase price. The relative return thresholds recompute reinvestment prices at each tested terminal value. That is the stricter of the two entry hurdles at the close. The fixed-book earnings equivalents scale the required ROE against modeled average common book in year five. They describe the threshold with book held fixed. An operating re-underwrite would recalculate earnings retention, book and CET1.
| Test at close | Year-five share price needed | Terminal ROE needed | Extra annual common earnings at fixed book |
|---|---|---|---|
| Match XIC | $149.29 | 15.86% | $4.37B |
| Beat XIC by two points | $165.33 | 17.24% | $5.79B |
| Cover the close at the cost of equity | $173.63 | 17.96% | $6.53B |
Analyst Assessment
Base is the central case and remains the entry reference. The relative-return ceiling is C$82.08. The worksheet solves for the purchase price that produces XIC’s annualized after-cost return plus two percentage points and recomputes the reinvestment path at each purchase price. Discounted fair value remains the binding limit. An early look at actual FY2027 credit costs, margin and RWA would provide better grounds for any change than extrapolating one strong Q3.
Operating Risks
A 10 bp drag on starting earning-asset margin costs about C$942 million of pre-tax annual income at constant volumes. Review if group NIM falls below 2.40%, especially if high-cost time deposits absorb a larger mix. Wealth outflows and weaker dealer fees would add pressure to the 3% non-interest-income growth assumption. Q3 segment disclosures
Financial and Liquidity Risks
About 77% of Canadian residential mortgages were uninsured at July 31. Higher renewal payments could raise arrears. Q3 gross impaired loans were 1.00% of loans and acceptances. Review a provision rate above 75 bps or a new deterioration in LCR and NSFR from 126% and 116%. The bear case's 100 bp losses put CET1 close enough to the floor to restrict the dividend. Q3 credit and liquidity discussion
Regulatory and Legal Risks
An OSFI buffer increase, tighter local capital rules or conduct penalties can absorb the roughly C$2.90 billion July headroom above Peralta's floor. Below 12.5% actual CET1 would be a prompt to redo the distribution path. Review the next OSFI buffer announcement and local capital restrictions before attributing capacity to group buybacks. OSFI buffer framework · Q3 capital
Industry and Competitive Risks
Price-led deposit acquisition and mortgage competition can increase funding costs faster than loan yields. Compare Q4 NIM and loan growth separately, and track whether Canadian volume gains require lower pricing or more marketing expense. Fees can also leak to competing brokerages and fintechs without an obvious decline in lending volume. Competition Bureau report
Thesis-Specific Risks and Reconsideration Triggers
Test December 2 against 2.49% group margin, 60 bps or less of provisions and at least 13.0% CET1. Then reconcile realized share repurchases, the Jamaica acquisition and FY2027 normalized common earnings. Isolate the stated C$96 million reported KeyCorp contribution and C$55 million Chile charge. Group NIM below 2.40%, provision rate above 75 bps or CET1 below 12.5% increases bear weight. At a price near the November close, sustainable ROE still needs a path near 18%.
Environmental Factors
Scotiabank said it is withdrawing its interim financed-emissions intensity targets and its 2050 financed-emissions net-zero goal as of fiscal 2026. It continues to report exposures in areas including oil and gas, power, autos, agriculture and residential mortgages. Historical financed-emissions measurements are delayed for business lending, so underwriting should track borrower cash-flow sensitivity and collateral exposure directly. FY2025 sustainability report, printed pp. 67–68 and 89–92
Social Factors
Client data, fraud losses and access to services affect retention and remediation expense. The bank reports that more than 556,000 clients used its Cybersecurity and Fraud Hub in 2025 and describes quarterly cyber oversight. This is a participation measure. The bank does not separately publish the associated loss avoided or program earnings, so valuation treats these effects through aggregate expense and credit costs. FY2025 sustainability report, printed p. 32
Governance Factors
The 2026 proxy describes audit and conduct review, risk oversight and variable pay adjusted for risk. The committee's metrics include earnings growth and relative shareholder return. With a high P/B, payout incentives need to be assessed against CET1 and buyback price per common share. Reconcile actual capital deployment with common book, especially when the authorization expands. 2026 management proxy, corporate governance and compensation
Financially Material Risks and Opportunities
Climate-linked insurance and collateral risks can raise loss severity in Canadian mortgages, and transition losses can affect commercial loans and RWA. Cyber and conduct failures would raise remediation expense and possibly funding costs. The 2025 sustainability report and July Q3 report do not provide a standalone cash or CET1 bridge for those exposures. Scenario provisions and operating expenses capture deterioration in aggregate, with the next separate disclosure a trigger to sharpen valuation. FY2025 sustainability report · Q3 risk management
Annual Results
CAD millions, fiscal years ended October 31. Source: consolidated income statements, physical PDF p. 150, and common earnings bridge in the reports. FY2025 report · FY2023 report
| CAD millions | FY2025 Oct 31 | FY2024 Oct 31 | FY2023 Oct 31 | FY2022 Oct 31 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interest Income | 57,602 | 61,659 | 56,824 | 33,558 |
| Interest Expense | 36,080 | 42,407 | 38,537 | 15,443 |
| Net Interest Income | 21,522 | 19,252 | 18,287 | 18,115 |
| Non-interest Income | 16,219 | 14,418 | 14,020 | 13,301 |
| Total Revenue | 37,741 | 33,670 | 32,307 | 31,416 |
| Provision for Credit Losses | 4,714 | 4,051 | 3,422 | 1,382 |
| Non-interest Expenses | 22,518 | 19,695 | 19,131 | 17,102 |
| Pretax Income | 10,509 | 9,924 | 9,754 | 12,932 |
| Income Tax Expense | 2,751 | 2,032 | 2,226 | 2,758 |
| Net Income | 7,758 | 7,892 | 7,528 | 10,174 |
| Preferred and Other Equity Claims | 506 | 472 | 419 | 260 |
| Common Earnings | 7,283 | 7,286 | 6,991 | 9,656 |
Interim Results
CAD millions, consolidated periods ended July 31. Q3 consolidated income statement, p. 62
| CAD millions | Q3 FY2026 Jul 31 | Q3 FY2025 Jul 31 | 9M FY2026 Jul 31 | 9M FY2025 Jul 31 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interest Income | 14,027 | 14,120 | 40,453 | 43,387 |
| Interest Expense | 8,161 | 8,627 | 23,484 | 27,451 |
| Net Interest Income | 5,866 | 5,493 | 16,969 | 15,936 |
| Non-interest Income | 4,669 | 3,993 | 13,049 | 12,002 |
| Total Revenue | 10,535 | 9,486 | 30,018 | 27,938 |
| Provision for Credit Losses | 1,079 | 1,041 | 3,472 | 3,601 |
| Non-interest Expenses | 5,556 | 5,089 | 16,044 | 16,690 |
| Pretax Income | 3,900 | 3,356 | 10,502 | 7,647 |
| Income Tax Expense | 947 | 829 | 2,618 | 2,095 |
| Net Income | 2,953 | 2,527 | 7,884 | 5,552 |
| Preferred and Other Equity Claims | 130 | 134 | 389 | 391 |
| Common Earnings | 2,778 | 2,313 | 7,401 | 5,179 |
Trailing Results
Twelve months ended July 31, 2026 in CAD millions, calculated as FY2025 plus 9M FY2026 minus 9M FY2025.
| CAD millions | 12M Jul 31, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Interest Income | 54,668 |
| Interest Expense | 32,113 |
| Net Interest Income | 22,555 |
| Non-interest Income | 17,266 |
| Total Revenue | 39,821 |
| Provision for Credit Losses | 4,585 |
| Non-interest Expenses | 21,872 |
| Pretax Income | 13,364 |
| Income Tax Expense | 3,274 |
| Net Income | 10,090 |
| Preferred and Other Equity Claims | 504 |
| Common Earnings | 9,505 |
Material Adjustments
Reported totals above retain impairments, divestiture effects, intangible amortization and taxes. The model instead annualizes Q3 2026 operating lines and estimates normalized credit loss and common claims. Q3 reported common earnings of C$2.778 billion compare with C$2.798 billion adjusted. Nine-month reported C$7.401 billion compare with C$7.827 billion adjusted. Q3 adjustments
Annual Positions
CAD millions at October 31. Total equity includes the three classes of claim shown. FY2025 consolidated financial position, p. 149 · FY2023 consolidated financial position, p. 149
| CAD millions | FY2025 Oct 31 | FY2024 Oct 31 | FY2023 Oct 31 | FY2022 Oct 31 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash and Deposits with Financial Institutions | 65,967 | 63,860 | 90,312 | 65,895 |
| Trading Assets | 152,223 | 129,727 | 117,868 | 113,154 |
| Securities Purchased under Resale Agreements | 203,008 | 200,543 | 199,325 | 175,313 |
| Derivative Financial Assets | 46,531 | 44,379 | 51,340 | 55,699 |
| Investment Securities | 149,948 | 152,832 | 118,237 | 110,008 |
| Gross Loans | 778,508 | 767,365 | 757,283 | 750,335 |
| Allowance for Credit Losses | 7,463 | 6,536 | 6,372 | 5,348 |
| Net Loans | 771,045 | 760,829 | 750,911 | 744,987 |
| Other Assets | 66,164 | 57,317 | 82,796 | 84,362 |
| Total Assets | 1,460,042 | 1,412,027 | 1,410,789 | 1,349,418 |
| Deposits | 966,279 | 943,849 | 952,333 | 916,181 |
| Financial Instruments at Fair Value through Profit or Loss | 47,165 | 36,341 | 26,779 | 22,421 |
| Other Liabilities | 358,011 | 347,761 | 353,010 | 336,067 |
| Total Liabilities | 1,371,455 | 1,327,951 | 1,332,122 | 1,274,669 |
| Common Equity | 76,927 | 73,590 | 68,853 | 65,150 |
| Preferred Shares and Other Equity Instruments | 9,939 | 8,779 | 8,075 | 8,075 |
| Non-controlling Interests | 1,721 | 1,707 | 1,739 | 1,524 |
| Stockholders Equity | 88,587 | 84,076 | 78,667 | 74,749 |
Interim Positions
CAD millions at quarter-end, except ratios. Q3 statement of financial position, p. 61 · Capital note, p. 81
| CAD millions | Jul 31, 2026 | Apr 30, 2026 | Oct 31, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash and Deposits with Financial Institutions | 62,455 | 79,301 | 65,967 |
| Trading Assets | 162,526 | 157,689 | 152,223 |
| Securities Purchased under Resale Agreements | 273,638 | 253,177 | 203,008 |
| Derivative Financial Assets | 50,531 | 46,709 | 46,531 |
| Investment Securities | 152,681 | 149,806 | 149,948 |
| Gross Loans | 777,884 | 764,584 | 778,508 |
| Allowance for Credit Losses | 7,329 | 7,150 | 7,463 |
| Net Loans | 770,555 | 757,434 | 771,045 |
| Other Assets | 69,973 | 67,205 | 66,164 |
| Total Assets | 1,548,267 | 1,521,521 | 1,460,042 |
| Deposits | 1,006,015 | 981,489 | 966,279 |
| Financial Instruments at Fair Value through Profit or Loss | 52,864 | 48,629 | 47,165 |
| Other Liabilities | 398,766 | 402,821 | 358,011 |
| Total Liabilities | 1,457,645 | 1,432,939 | 1,371,455 |
| Common Equity | 79,212 | 77,222 | 76,927 |
| Preferred Shares and Other Equity Instruments | 9,939 | 9,939 | 9,939 |
| Non-controlling Interests | 1,471 | 1,421 | 1,721 |
| Stockholders Equity | 90,622 | 88,582 | 88,587 |
| CET1 capital | 64,508 | 62,972 | 62,752 |
| RWA | 492,866 | 474,440 | 474,453 |
| CET1 ratio | 13.1% | 13.3% | 13.2% |
Capital and Claims Reconciliation
July total equity of C$90.622 billion consists of C$79.212 billion common, C$9.939 billion preferred and other instruments and C$1.471 billion non-controlling interests. Common book comprises C$21.899 billion share capital, C$60.391 billion retained earnings, negative C$3.020 billion AOCI and negative C$58 million other reserves. CET1 is a distinct regulatory number after adjustments. C$64.508 billion divided by C$492.866 billion RWA gives 13.09%. Deposits and debt are operating funding with costs reflected in NII, and non-common equity and minority claims are treated before per-share valuation. Q3 consolidated financial position · Q3 capital note
Annual Flows
CAD millions, years ended October 31. Negative figures are outflows. FY2025 consolidated cash flow statement, p. 153 · FY2023 consolidated cash flow statement, p. 153
| CAD millions | FY2025 Oct 31 | FY2024 Oct 31 | FY2023 Oct 31 | FY2022 Oct 31 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net Income | 7,758 | 7,892 | 7,528 | 10,174 |
| Trading Assets Change | -20,462 | -11,370 | -2,689 | 37,501 |
| Loans Change | -6,591 | -17,712 | 4,414 | -97,161 |
| Deposits Change | 19,533 | -816 | 19,478 | 95,905 |
| Operating Cash Flow | 5,407 | 15,652 | 31,724 | 16,943 |
| Investing Cash Flow | 1,568 | -7,450 | -30,040 | -11,293 |
| Financing Cash Flow | -6,308 | -8,838 | -2,766 | -4,579 |
| Common Shares Purchased for Cancellation | -895 | 0 | 0 | -2,873 |
| Cash Dividends and Distributions Paid | -5,875 | -5,670 | -5,422 | -5,118 |
| Effect Of Exchange Rate Changes | 183 | -131 | 190 | 301 |
| Change In Cash | 850 | -767 | -892 | 1,372 |
| Beginning Cash Position | 9,406 | 10,173 | 11,065 | 9,693 |
| End Cash Position | 10,256 | 9,406 | 10,173 | 11,065 |
Interim Flows
CAD millions, consolidated periods ended July 31. Q3 consolidated cash flows, p. 65
| CAD millions | Q3 FY2026 Jul 31 | Q3 FY2025 Jul 31 | 9M FY2026 Jul 31 | 9M FY2025 Jul 31 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net Income | 2,953 | 2,527 | 7,884 | 5,552 |
| Trading Assets Change | -2,066 | -7,000 | -10,289 | -6,066 |
| Loans Change | -7,544 | -4,615 | -18,042 | -2,982 |
| Deposits Change | 13,689 | 1,418 | 60,931 | 6,605 |
| Operating Cash Flow | -16,807 | 4,383 | 13,144 | 11,596 |
| Investing Cash Flow | 19,045 | 168 | -5,473 | -3,092 |
| Financing Cash Flow | -1,196 | -3,677 | -7,658 | -6,191 |
| Common Shares Purchased for Cancellation | -1,011 | -240 | -2,138 | -240 |
| Cash Dividends and Distributions Paid | -1,521 | -1,501 | -4,490 | -4,399 |
| Effect Of Exchange Rate Changes | 184 | 38 | 60 | 1 |
| Change In Cash | 1,226 | 912 | 73 | 2,314 |
| Beginning Cash Position | 9,103 | 10,808 | 10,256 | 9,406 |
| End Cash Position | 10,329 | 11,720 | 10,329 | 11,720 |
Trailing Flows
CAD millions. FY2025 plus 9M FY2026 minus 9M FY2025. Cash balance rolls forward from the prior July closing amount.
| CAD millions | 12M Jul 31, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Net Income | 10,090 |
| Trading Assets Change | -24,685 |
| Loans Change | -21,651 |
| Deposits Change | 73,859 |
| Operating Cash Flow | 6,955 |
| Investing Cash Flow | -813 |
| Financing Cash Flow | -7,775 |
| Common Shares Purchased for Cancellation | -2,793 |
| Cash Dividends and Distributions Paid | -5,966 |
| Effect Of Exchange Rate Changes | 242 |
| Change In Cash | -1,391 |
| Beginning Cash Position | 11,720 |
| End Cash Position | 10,329 |
Reconciliation to Common Shareholders
Cash dividends and distributions include senior equity payouts. FY2025's C$5.875 billion comprised C$5.369 billion of common dividends (C$4.32/share) and C$506 million of other equity amounts. The bank paid C$3.34 per common share in the nine months ended July 31, and the cash flow statement also shows C$2.138 billion in nine-month common share repurchases. Normalized common earnings less retained capital is the basis for modeled distribution capacity. Reported operating cash flow includes deposits and loans and has no direct industrial free-cash-flow interpretation. FY2025 equity note · FY2025 cash flow · Q3 highlights and cash flow
Primary Sources and Locators
The public capital exhibit is Peralta's exhibit of Q3 source facts. The original issuer locations are the July balance sheet (p. 61), capital note (p. 81), share note (p. 80) and highlights (p. 4). The source ledger identifies the original publisher and period for statements, competition, ownership, sustainability, rates, quotes and the relative-return comparator. Q3 issuer filing
Frozen Inputs and Assumptions
The bank packet dates financials to July 31 and the quote to November 19 and carries governed scenario assumptions and source identifiers. The five-year Python specifies the expansion of volume, margin, credit, expenses, tax, distribution floor and trading assumptions. Scotiabank's issuer outlook and Q4 account changes remain separate from Peralta forecasts.
Worksheets and Saved Outputs
Run the decision worksheet with Python 3.12 to reproduce the governed anchor, exact five-year output and supplementary decision tables offline. The linked worksheet includes five annual rows per case. In the first two forecast years, modeled earnings, RWA, credit losses and distributions pass through bank-common-book-v1. The next three use the same consolidated drivers and distribution floor.
Changes from the Preceding Edition
The November 19 predecessor was reproduced from its frozen inputs. This revision retains its November 19 market cutoff and July 31 financial baseline. The revised return comparison reinvests BNS dividends in BNS. Base annualized return at the close rises from 0.11% to 0.15% and the XIC-plus-two-points ceiling moves from C$78.93 to C$82.08. Fair value and rounded maximum entry carry over. The added benchmark cross-check, price tests and reverse valuation quantify what could change the decision. The completed Jamaica acquisition is added to the Q4 capital reconciliation. The first quantitative update to those balances depends on the FY2026 statements.
| Revision driver | Fair value | Maximum entry |
|---|---|---|
| Prior | $78.84 | $78.00 |
| Reinvest dividends in BNS and recheck the XIC hurdle | +0.00 | +0.00 |
| Rounding | +0.00 | +0.00 |
| Current | $78.84 | $78.00 |